The Unbelievable Zombie Comeback of Analog Computing
ILLUSTRATION: KHYATI TREHAN
CHARLES PLATT
THE BIG STORY
MAR 30, 2023 6:00 AM
The Unbelievable Zombie Comeback of Analog Computing
Computers have been digital for half a century. Why would anyone want to resurrect the clunkers of yesteryear?
Let's Get Physical
How to Love Tech Again
I Saw God in a Chip Factory
The Never-Ending Fight to
Repair
The Future Is Analog
Now Reading
Who’s Watching the
Watchers?
Weapons of Gas Disruption
Listen to this story
00:00
31:09
1x
15
MOST POPULAR
15
POLITICS
machines to come crawling back from oblivion. Floppy diskettes, VHS tapes, cathode-
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
ray tubes—they shall rest in peace. Likewise, we won’t see old analog computers in data
BY DAVID GILBERT
WHEN OLD TECH dies, it usually stays dead. No one expects rotary phones or adding
centers anytime soon. They were monstrous beasts: difficult to program, expensive to
maintain, and limited in accuracy.
POLITICS
Or so I thought. Then I came across this confounding statement:
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
BY MAKENA KELLY
Bringing back analog computers in much more advanced forms than their historic
ancestors will change the world of computing drastically and forever.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
The most ambitious, future-defining stories from our
favorite writers.
BY JASON KOEBLER
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
SIGN UP
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
By signing up, you agree to our user agreement (including class action waiver and arbitration provisions), and acknowledge our
privacy policy.
BY LAUREN GOODE
Seriously?
I found the prediction in the preface of a handsome illustrated book titled, simply,
Analog Computing. Reissued in 2022, it was written by the German mathematician
Bernd Ulmann—who seemed very serious indeed.
I’ve been writing about future tech since before
WIRED existed and have written six books
explaining electronics. I used to develop my own
software, and some of my friends design
hardware. I’d never heard anyone say anything
about analog, so why would Ulmann imagine that
this very dead paradigm could be resurrected? And
with such far-reaching and permanent
consequences?
I felt compelled to investigate further.
FOR AN EX AMPLE of how digital has displaced
analog, look at photography. In a pre-digital
This article appears in the May 2023
issue. Subscribe to WIRED. ILLUSTRATION:
ALVARO DOMINGUEZ
camera, continuous variations in light created
chemical reactions on a piece of film, where an
image appeared as a representation—an analogue—of reality. In a modern camera, by
contrast, the light variations are converted to digital values. These are processed by the
camera’s CPU before being saved as a stream of 1s and 0s—with digital compression, if
you wish.
Engineers began using the word analog in the 1940s (shortened from analogue; they
like compression) to refer to computers that simulated real-world conditions. But
mechanical devices had been doing much the same thing for centuries.
The Antikythera mechanism was an astonishingly complex piece of machinery used
thousands of years ago in ancient Greece. Containing at least 30 bronze gears, it
displayed the everyday movements of the moon, sun, and five planets while also
MOST POPULAR
predicting solar and lunar eclipses. Because its mechanical workings simulated real-
POLITICS
world celestial events, it is regarded as one of the earliest analog computers.
As the centuries passed, mechanical analog devices were fabricated for earthlier
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
purposes. In the 1800s, an invention called the planimeter consisted of a little wheel, a
BY DAVID GILBERT
shaft, and a linkage. You traced a pointer around the edge of a shape on a piece of
paper, and the area of the shape was displayed on a scale. The tool became an
POLITICS
indispensable item in real-estate offices when buyers wanted to know the acreage of an
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
irregularly shaped piece of land.
BY MAKENA KELLY
Other gadgets served military needs. If you were on a battleship trying to aim a 16-inch
gun at a target beyond the horizon, you needed to assess the orientation of your ship, its
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
motion, its position, and the direction and speed of the wind; clever mechanical
components allowed the operator to input these factors and adjust the gun
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
appropriately. Gears, linkages, pulleys, and levers could also predict tides or calculate
BY JASON KOEBLER
distances on a map.
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
In the 1940s, electronic components such as vacuum tubes and resistors were added,
because a fluctuating current flowing through them could be analogous to the behavior
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
of fluids, gases, and other phenomena in the physical world. A varying voltage could
BY LAUREN GOODE
represent the velocity of a Nazi V2 missile fired at London, for example, or the
orientation of a Gemini space capsule in a 1963 flight simulator.
But by then, analog had become a dying art. Instead of using a voltage to represent the
velocity of a missile and electrical resistance to represent the air resistance slowing it
down, a digital computer could convert variables to binary code—streams of 1s and 0s
that were suitable for processing. Early digital computers were massive mainframes full
of vacuum tubes, but then integrated circuit chips made digital processing cheaper,
more reliable, and more versatile. By the 1970s, the analog-digital difference could be
summarized like this:
The last factor was a big deal, as the accuracy of analog computers was always limited
by their components. Whether you used gear wheels or vacuum tubes or chemical film,
precision was limited by manufacturing tolerances and deteriorated with age. Analog
was always modeled on the real world, and the world was never absolutely precise.
WHEN I WAS a nerdy British schoolboy with a mild case of OCD, inaccuracy bothered
me a lot. I revered Pythagoras, who told me that a triangle with sides of 3 centimeters
and 4 centimeters adjacent to a 90-degree angle would have a diagonal side of 5
centimeters, precisely. Alas, my pleasure diminished when I realized that his proof only
applied in a theoretical realm where lines were of zero thickness.
In my everyday realm, precision was limited by my ability to sharpen a pencil, and
when I tried to make measurements, I ran into another bothersome feature of reality.
Using a magnifying glass, I compared the ruler that I’d bought at a stationery store with
MOST POPULAR
a ruler in our school’s physics lab, and discovered that they were not exactly the same
POLITICS
length.
How could this be? Seeking enlightenment, I checked the history of the metric system.
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
The meter was the fundamental unit, but it had been birthed from a bizarre
BY DAVID GILBERT
combination of nationalism and whimsy. After the French Revolution, the new
government instituted the meter to get away from the imprecision of the ancien régime.
POLITICS
The French Academy of Sciences defined it as the longitudinal distance from the
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
equator, through Paris, to the North Pole, divided by 10 million. In 1799, the meter was
solemnified like a religious totem in the form of a platinum bar at the French National
BY MAKENA KELLY
Archives. Copies were made and distributed across Europe and to the Americas, and
then copies were made of the copies’ copies. This process introduced transcription
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
errors, which eventually led to my traumatic discovery that rulers from different
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
sources might be visibly unequal.
BY JASON KOEBLER
Similar problems impeded any definitive measurement of time, temperature, and mass.
The conclusion was inescapable to my adolescent mind: If you were hoping for absolute
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
precision in the physical realm, you couldn’t have it.
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
My personal term for the inexact nature of the messy, fuzzy world was muzzy. But then,
BY LAUREN GOODE
in 1980, I acquired an Ohio Scientific desktop computer and found prompt, lasting
relief. All its operations were built on a foundation of binary arithmetic, in which a 1 was
always exactly a 1 and a 0 was a genuine 0, with no fractional quibbling. The 1 of
existence, and the 0 of nothingness! I fell in love with the purity of digital and learned
to write code, which became a lifelong refuge from muzzy math.
Of course, digital values still had to be stored in fallible physical components, but
margins of error took care of that. In a modern 5-volt digital chip, 1.5 volts or lower
would represent the number 0 while 3.5 volts or greater would represent the number 1.
MOST POPULAR
Components on a decently engineered motherboard would stay within those limits, so
POLITICS
there shouldn’t have been any misunderstandings.
Consequently, when Bernd Ulmann predicted that analog computers were due for a
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
zombie comeback, I wasn’t just skeptical. I found the idea a bit … disturbing.
BY DAVID GILBERT
HOPING FOR A reality check, I consulted Lyle Bickley, a founding member of the
POLITICS
Computer History Museum in Mountain View, California. Having served for years as an
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
expert witness in patent suits, Bickley maintains an encyclopedic knowledge of
everything that has been done and is still being done in data processing.
BY MAKENA KELLY
“A lot of Silicon Valley companies have secret projects doing analog chips,” he told me.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Really? But why?
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
“Because they take so little power.”
BY JASON KOEBLER
Bickley explained that when, say, brute-force natural-language AI systems distill
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
millions of words from the internet, the process is insanely power hungry. The human
brain runs on a small amount of electricity, he said, about 20 watts. (That’s the same as
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
a light bulb.) “Yet if we try to do the same thing with digital computers, it takes
BY LAUREN GOODE
megawatts.” For that kind of application, digital is “not going to work. It’s not a smart
way to do it.”
Bickley said he would be violating confidentiality to tell me specifics, so I went looking
for startups. Quickly I found a San Francisco Bay Area company called Mythic, which
claimed to be marketing the “industry-first AI analog matrix processor.”
Mike Henry cofounded Mythic at the University of Michigan in 2013. He’s an energetic
guy with a neat haircut and a well-ironed shirt, like an old-time IBM salesman. He
expanded on Bickley’s point, citing the brain-like neural network that powers GPT-3. “It
has 175 billion synapses,” Henry said, comparing processing elements with connections
between neurons in the brain. “So every time you run that model to do one thing, you
have to load 175 billion values. Very large data-center systems can barely keep up.”
That’s because, Henry said, they are digital. Modern AI systems use a type of memory
called static RAM, or SRAM, which requires constant power to store data. Its circuitry
must remain switched on even when it’s not performing a task. Engineers have done a
MOST POPULAR
lot to improve the efficiency of SRAM, but there’s a limit. “Tricks like lowering the
POLITICS
supply voltage are running out,” Henry said.
Mythic’s analog chip uses less power by storing neural weights not in SRAM but in flash
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
memory, which doesn’t consume power to retain its state. And the flash memory is
BY DAVID GILBERT
embedded in a processing chip, a configuration Mythic calls “compute-in-memory.”
Instead of consuming a lot of power moving millions of bytes back and forth between
POLITICS
memory and a CPU (as a digital computer does), some processing is done locally.
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
What bothered me was that Mythic seemed to be reintroducing the accuracy problems
BY MAKENA KELLY
of analog. The flash memory was not storing a 1 or 0 with comfortable margins of error,
like old-school logic chips. It was holding intermediate voltages (as many as 256 of
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
them!) to simulate the varying states of neurons in the brain, and I had to wonder
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
whether those voltages would drift over time. Henry didn’t seem to think they would.
BY JASON KOEBLER
I had another problem with his chip: The way it worked was hard to explain. Henry
laughed. “Welcome to my life,” he said. “Try explaining it to venture capitalists.” Mythic’s
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
success on that front has been variable: Shortly after I spoke to Henry, the company ran
out of cash. (More recently it raised $13 million in new funding and appointed a new
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
CEO.)
BY LAUREN GOODE
I next went to IBM. Its corporate PR department connected me with Vijay Narayanan, a
researcher in the company’s physics-of-AI department. He preferred to interact via
company-sanctioned email statements.
For the moment, Narayanan wrote, “our analog research is about customizing AI
hardware, particularly for energy efficiency.” So, the same goal as Mythic. However,
Narayanan seemed rather circumspect on the details, so I did some more reading and
MOST POPULAR
found an IBM paper that referred to “no appreciable accuracy loss” in its memory
POLITICS
systems. No appreciable loss? Did that mean there was some loss? Then there was the
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
durability issue. Another paper mentioned “an accuracy above 93.5 percent retained
over a one-day period.” So it had lost 6.5 percent in just one day? Was that bad? What
should it be compared to?
BY DAVID GILBERT
So many unanswered questions, but the biggest letdown was this: Both Mythic and IBM
POLITICS
seemed interested in analog computing only insofar as specific analog processes could
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
reduce the energy and storage requirements of AI—not perform the fundamental bitbased calculations. (The digital components would still do that.) As far as I could tell,
BY MAKENA KELLY
this wasn’t anything close to the second coming of analog as predicted by Ulmann. The
computers of yesteryear may have been room-sized behemoths, but they could
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
simulate everything from liquid flowing through a pipe to nuclear reactions. Their
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
applications shared one attribute. They were dynamic. They involved the concept of
BY JASON KOEBLER
change.
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
BY LAUREN GOODE
Engineers began using the word analog in the 1940s to refer to computers that simulated real-world conditions. ILLUSTRATION:
KHYATI TREHAN
ANOTHER CHILDHOOD CONUNDRUM: If I held a ball and dropped it, the force of
gravity made it move at an increasing speed. How could you figure out the total
distance the ball traveled if the speed was changing continuously over time? You could
MOST POPULAR
break its journey down into seconds or milliseconds or microseconds, work out the
POLITICS
speed at each step, and add up the distances. But if time actually flowed in tiny steps,
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
the speed would have to jump instantaneously between one step and the next. How
could that be true?
BY DAVID GILBERT
Later I learned that these questions had been addressed by Isaac Newton and Gottfried
Leibniz centuries ago. They’d said that velocity does change in increments, but the
POLITICS
increments are infinitely small.
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
So there were steps, but they weren’t really steps? It sounded like an evasion to me, but
BY MAKENA KELLY
on this iffy premise, Newton and Leibniz developed calculus, enabling everyone to
calculate the behavior of countless naturally changing aspects of the world. Calculus is
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
a way of mathematically modeling something that’s continuously changing, like the
distance traversed by a falling ball, as a sequence of infinitely small differences: a
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
differential equation.
BY JASON KOEBLER
That math could be used as the input to old-school analog electronic computers—often
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
called, for this reason, differential analyzers. You could plug components together to
represent operations in an equation, set some values using potentiometers, and the
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
answer could be shown almost immediately as a trace on an oscilloscope screen. It
BY LAUREN GOODE
might not have been ideally accurate, but in the muzzy world, as I had learned to my
discontent, nothing was ideally accurate.
To be competitive, a true analog computer that could emulate such versatile behavior
would have to be suitable for low-cost mass production—on the scale of a silicon chip.
Had such a thing been developed? I went back to Ulmann’s book and found the answer
on the penultimate page. A researcher named Glenn Cowan had created a genuine VLSI
(very large-scale integrated circuit) analog chip back in 2003. Ulmann complained that
it was “limited in capabilities,” but it sounded like the real deal.
GLENN COWAN IS a studious, methodical, amiable man and a professor in electrical
engineering at Montreal’s Concordia University. As a grad student at Columbia back in
1999, he had a choice between two research topics: One would entail optimizing a
MOST POPULAR
single transistor, while the other would be to develop an entirely new analog computer.
POLITICS
The latter was the pet project of an adviser named Yannis Tsividis. “Yannis sort of
convinced me,” Cowan told me, sounding as if he wasn’t quite sure how it happened.
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
Initially, there were no specifications, because no one had ever built an analog
BY DAVID GILBERT
computer on a chip. Cowan didn’t know how accurate it could be and was basically
making it up as he went along. He had to take other courses at Columbia to fill the gaps
POLITICS
in his knowledge. Two years later, he had a test chip that, he told me modestly, was “full
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
of graduate-student naivete. It looked like a breadboarding nightmare.” Still, it worked,
so he decided to stick around and make a better version. That took another two years.
BY MAKENA KELLY
A key innovation of Cowan’s was making the chip reconfigurable—or programmable.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Old-school analog computers had used clunky patch cords on plug boards. Cowan did
the same thing in miniature, between areas on the chip itself, using a preexisting
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
technology known as transmission gates. These can work as solid-state switches to
BY JASON KOEBLER
connect the output from processing block A to the input of block B, or block C, or any
other block you choose.
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
His second innovation was to make his analog chip compatible with an off-the-shelf
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
digital computer, which could help to circumvent limits on precision. “You could get an
BY LAUREN GOODE
approximate analog solution as a starting point,” Cowan explained, “and feed that into
the digital computer as a guess, because iterative routines converge faster from a good
guess.” The end result of his great labor was etched onto a silicon wafer measuring a
very respectable 10 millimeters by 10 millimeters. “Remarkably,” he told me, “it did
work.”
When I asked Cowan about real-world uses, inevitably he mentioned AI. But I’d had
some time to think about neural nets and was beginning to feel skeptical. In a standard
neural net setup, known as a crossbar configuration, each cell in the net connects with
MOST POPULAR
four other cells. They may be layered to allow for extra connections, but even so, they’re
POLITICS
far less complex than the frontal cortex of the brain, in which each individual neuron
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
can be connected with 10,000 others. Moreover, the brain is not a static network.
During the first year of life, new neural connections form at a rate of 1 million per
second. I saw no way for a neural network to emulate processes like that.
BY DAVID GILBERT
GLENN COWAN’S SECOND analog chip wasn’t the end of the story at Columbia.
POLITICS
Additional refinements were necessary, but Yannis Tsividis had to wait for another
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
graduate student who would continue the work.
BY MAKENA KELLY
In 2011 a soft-spoken young man named Ning Guo turned out to be willing. Like Cowan,
he had never designed a chip before. “I found it, um, pretty challenging,” he told me. He
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
laughed at the memory and shook his head. “We were too optimistic,” he recalled
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
ruefully. He laughed again. “Like we thought we could get it done by the summer.”
BY JASON KOEBLER
In fact, it took more than a year to complete the chip design. Guo said Tsividis had
required a “90 percent confidence level” that the chip would work before he would
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
proceed with the expensive process of fabrication. Guo took a chance, and the result he
named the HCDC, meaning hybrid continuous discrete computer. Guo’s prototype was
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
then incorporated on a board that could interface with an off-the-shelf digital
BY LAUREN GOODE
computer. From the outside, it looked like an accessory circuit board for a PC.
When I asked Guo about possible applications, he had to think for a bit. Instead of
mentioning AI, he suggested tasks such as simulating a lot of moving mechanical joints
that would be rigidly connected to each other in robotics. Then, unlike many engineers,
he allowed himself to speculate.
There are diminishing returns on the digital model, he said, yet it still dominates the
industry. “If we applied as many people and as much money to the analog domain, I
think we could have some kind of analog coprocessing happening to accelerate the
MOST POPULAR
existing algorithms. Digital computers are very good at scalability. Analog is very good
POLITICS
at complex interactions between variables. In the future, we may combine these
advantages.”
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
THE HCDC WAS fully functional, but it had a problem: It was not easy to use.
BY DAVID GILBERT
Fortuitously, a talented programmer at MIT named Sara Achour read about the project
and saw it as an ideal target for her skills. She was a specialist in compilers—programs
POLITICS
that convert a high-level programming language into machine language—and could
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
add a more user-friendly front end in Python to help people program the chip. She
reached out to Tsividis, and he sent her one of the few precious boards that had been
BY MAKENA KELLY
fabricated.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
When I spoke with Achour, she was entertaining and engaging, delivering terminology
at a manic pace. She told me she had originally intended to be a doctor but switched to
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
computer science after having pursued programming as a hobby since middle school. “I
BY JASON KOEBLER
had specialized in math modeling of biological systems,” she said. “We did macroscopic
modeling of gene protein hormonal dynamics.” Seeing my blank look, she added: “We
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
were trying to predict things like hormonal changes when you inject someone with a
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
particular drug.”
BY LAUREN GOODE
Changes was the key word. She was fully acquainted with the math to describe change,
and after two years she finished her compiler for the analog chip. “I didn’t build, like, an
entry-level product,” she said. “But I made it easier to find resilient implementations of
the computation you want to run. You see, even the people who design this type of
hardware have difficulty programming it. It’s still extremely painful.”
I liked the idea of a former medical student alleviating the pain of chip designers who
had difficulty using their own hardware. But what was her take on applications? Are
there any?
MOST POPULAR
POLITICS
“Yes, whenever you’re sensing the environment,” she said. “And reconfigurability lets
going to be relegated to a niche model. Analog computation makes a lot of sense when
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
you’re interfacing with something that is inherently analog.” Like the real world, with all
BY DAVID GILBERT
you reuse the same piece of hardware for multiple computations. So I don’t think this is
its muzziness.
POLITICS
GOING BACK TO the concept of dropping a ball, and my interest in finding out how far
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
it travels during a period of time: Calculus solves that problem easily, with a differential
equation—if you ignore air resistance. The proper term for this is “integrating velocity
with respect to time.”
BY MAKENA KELLY
But what if you don’t ignore air resistance? The faster the ball falls, the more air
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
resistance it encounters. But gravity remains constant, so the ball’s speed doesn’t
increase at a steady rate but tails off until it reaches terminal velocity. You can express
BY JASON KOEBLER
this in a differential equation too, but it adds another layer of complexity. I won’t get
into the mathematical notation (I prefer to avoid the pain of it, to use Sara Achour’s
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
memorable term), because the take-home message is all that matters. Every time you
introduce another factor, the scenario gets more complicated. If there’s a crosswind, or
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
the ball collides with other balls, or it falls down a hole to the center of the Earth, where
BY LAUREN GOODE
gravity is zero—the situation can get discouragingly complicated.
Now suppose you want to simulate the scenario using a digital computer. It’ll need a lot
of data points to generate a smooth curve, and it’ll have to continually recalculate all
the values for each point. Those calculations will add up, especially if multiple objects
become involved. If you have billions of objects—as in a nuclear chain reaction, or
synapse states in an AI engine—you’ll need a digital processor containing maybe 100
billion transistors to crunch the data at billions of cycles per second. And in each cycle,
the switching operation of each transistor will generate heat. Waste heat becomes a
serious issue.
Using a new-age analog chip, you just express all the factors in a differential equation
and type it into Achour’s compiler, which converts the equation into machine language
that the chip understands. The brute force of binary code is minimized, and so is the
MOST POPULAR
power consumption and the heat. The HCDC is like an efficient little helper residing
POLITICS
secretly amid the modern hardware, and it’s chip-sized, unlike the room-sized
behemoths of yesteryear.
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
Now I should update the basic analog attributes:
BY DAVID GILBERT
POLITICS
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
BY MAKENA KELLY
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
BY JASON KOEBLER
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
BY LAUREN GOODE
You can see how the designs by Tsividis and his grad students have addressed the
historic disadvantages in my previous list. And yet, despite all this, Tsividis—the prophet
of modern analog computing—still has difficulty getting people to take him seriously.
BORN IN GREECE in 1946, Tsividis developed an early dislike for geography, history,
and chemistry. “I felt as if there were more facts to memorize than I had synapses in my
brain,” he told me. He loved math and physics but ran into a different problem when a
teacher assured him that the perimeter of any circle was three times the diameter plus
14 centimeters. Of course, it should be (approximately) 3.14 times the diameter of the
circle, but when Tsividis said so, the teacher told him to be quiet. This, he has said,
“suggested rather strongly that authority figures are not always right.”
He taught himself English, started learning electronics, designed and built devices like
radio transmitters, and eventually fled from the Greek college system that had
compelled him to learn organic chemistry. In 1972 he began graduate studies in the
United States, and over the years became known for challenging orthodoxy in the field
of computer science. One well-known circuit designer referred to him as “the analog
MOS freak,” after he designed and fabricated an amplifier chip in 1975 using metaloxide semiconductor technology, which absolutely no one believed was suitable for the
task.
These days, Tsividis is polite and down to earth, with no interest in wasting words. His
attempt to bring back analog in the form of integrated chips began in earnest in the late
’90s. When I talked to him, he told me he had 18 boards with analog chips mounted on
MOST POPULAR
them, a couple more having been loaned out to researchers such as Achour. “But the
POLITICS
project is on hold now,” he said, “because the funding ended from the National Science
Foundation. And then we had two years of Covid.”
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
I asked what he would do if he got new funding.
BY DAVID GILBERT
“I would need to know, if you put together many chips to model a large system, then
POLITICS
what happens? So we will try to put together many of those chips and eventually, with
the help of silicon foundries, make a large computer on a single chip.”
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
I pointed out that development so far has already taken almost 20 years.
BY MAKENA KELLY
“Yes, but there were several years of breaks in between. Whenever there is appropriate
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
funding, I revive the process.”
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
I asked him whether the state of analog computing today could be compared to that of
BY JASON KOEBLER
quantum computing 25 years ago. Could it follow a similar path of development, from
fringe consideration to common (and well-funded) acceptance?
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
It would take a fraction of the time, he said. “We have our experimental results. It has
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
proven itself. If there is a group that wants to make it user-friendly, within a year we
BY LAUREN GOODE
could have it.” And at this point he is willing to provide analog computer boards to
interested researchers, who can use them with Achour’s compiler.
What sort of people would qualify?
“The background you need is not just computers. You really need the math background
to know what differential equations are.”
I asked him whether he felt that his idea was, in a way, obvious. Why hadn’t it resonated
yet with more people?
MOST POPULAR
“People do wonder why we are doing this when everything is digital. They say digital is
the future, digital is the future—and of course it’s the future. But the physical world is
analog, and in between you have a big interface. That’s where this fits.”
POLITICS
He Wrote a Book About Antifa.
Death Threats Are Driving Him Out
of the US
BY DAVID GILBERT
POLITICS
Trump Wants to Take Over Cities.
Influencers Are Giving Him the Fuel
to Do It
BY MAKENA KELLY
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Meta Tells Its Metaverse Workers to
Use AI to ‘Go 5X Faster’
BY JASON KOEBLER
COMPUTERS AND SOFTWARE
Inside Intel's Hail Mary to Reclaim
Chip Dominance
BY LAUREN GOODE
In a digital processor crunching data at billions of cycles per second, the switching operation of each transistor generates heat.
ILLUSTRATION: KHYATI TREHAN
WHEN TSIVIDIS MENTIONED offhandedly that people applying analog computation
would need an appropriate math background, I started to wonder. Developing
algorithms for digital computers can be a strenuous mental exercise, but calculus is
seldom required. When I mentioned this to Achour, she laughed and said that when she
submits papers to reviewers, “Some of them say they haven’t seen differential equations
in years. Some of them have never seen differential equations.”
And no doubt a lot of them won’t want to. But financial incentives have a way of
overcoming resistance to change. Imagine a future where software engineers can
command an extra $100K per annum by adding a new bullet point to a résumé: “Fluent
in differential equations.” If that happens, I’m thinking Python developers will soon be
signing up for remedial online calculus classes.
Likewise, in business, the determining factor will be financial. There’s going to be a lot
of money in AI—and in smarter drug molecules, and in agile robots, and in a dozen
other applications that model the muzzy complexity of the physical world. If power
consumption and heat dissipation become really expensive problems, and shunting
some of the digital load into miniaturized analog coprocessors is significantly cheaper,
then no one will care that analog computation used to be done by your math-genius
grandfather using a big steel box full of vacuum tubes.
Reality really is imprecise, no matter how much I would prefer otherwise, and when
you want to model it with truly exquisite fidelity, digitizing it may not be the most
sensible method. Therefore, I must conclude:
Analog is dead.
Long live analog.
This article appears in the May issue. Subscribe now.
Let us know what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor at
mail@wired.com.
READ NEXT
WHO’S WATCHING THE WATCHERS?
You Might Also Like …
In your inbox: Our biggest stories, handpicked for you each day
Meet the guys betting big on AI gambling agents
Big Story: The baby died. Whose fault is it?
I hate my AI friend
Livestream replay: WIRED’s AI Power Summit
Charles Platt is a contributing editor at Make and the author of Make: Electronics, among other books. ...
Read More
TOPICS
LONGREADS
HARDWARE
HARDWARE ISSUE
ANALOG
COMPUTERS
COMPUTING
CODE
MAGAZINE-31.05
Get The Big Story in Your Inbox
The most ambitious, future-defining stories from our favorite writers.
SIGN UP
By signing up, you agree to our user agreement (including class action waiver and arbitration provisions), and acknowledge
our privacy policy.
READ MORE
Tech Billionaires Already Captured the
White House. They Still Want to Be
Kings
Mira Murati’s Stealth AI Lab Launches
Its First Product
Sam Altman Says the GPT-5 Haters Got
It All Wrong
Scientist Who Was Offline 'Living His
Best Life' Stunned by Nobel Prize Win
Thinking Machines Lab, led by a group of
OpenAI's CEO explains that its large language
Fred Ramsdell was on vacation in the Wyoming
From Montenegro to Northern California, the tech
prominent former OpenAI researchers, is betting
model has been misunderstood—and that he's
wilderness when he and two colleagues received
elite dream of building cities where they make
that fine-tuning cutting-edge models will be the
changed his attitude to AGI.
the honor for their breakthroughs in immunology.
the rules. Is this, finally, their moment?
next frontier in AI.
STEVEN LEVY
LOUISE MATSAKIS
VITTORIA ELLIOTT
WILL KNIGHT
Palantir Wants to Be a Lifestyle Brand
The LA Fires Spewed Out Toxic
Nanoparticles. He Made It His Mission
to Trace Them
The Quest to Find the LongestRunning Simple Computer Program
Move Aside, Chatbots: AI Humanoids
Are Here
The Busy Beaver Challenge, a notoriously difficult
Today on Uncanny Valley, we talk about why the
Nicholas Spada is one of the only scientists in the
question in theoretical computer science, is now
AI industry is investing in the development of
world using a nuclear x-ray process to study
producing answers so large they’re impossible to
humanoid robots, and what that means for us
deadly nanoparticles in wildfire smoke. What he’s
write out using standard mathematical notation.
non-robots.
BEN BRUBAKER
MICHAEL CALORE
Inside the Nuclear Bunkers, Mines, and
Mountains Being Retrofitted as Data
Centers
Patreon CEO Jack Conte Wants You to
Get Off of Your Phone
The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal
Workers
The man who cofounded Patreon is tired of
WIRED spoke with more than 200 federal
talk about standing up to content scraping, the
Companies are going to great lengths to protect
influencers making content to get clicks. He’d
workers in dozens of agencies to learn what
internet’s potential futures, and his company's
the infrastructure that provides the backbone of
rather creators earn lifelong fans—and he has a
happened as the Department of Government
relationship to Trump.
the world’s digital services—by burying their data
plan for that.
Efficiency tore through their offices.
KATIE DRUMMOND
AARIAN MARSHALL
Defense tech giant Palantir is selling T-shirts and
tote bags as part of a bid to encourage fans to
publicly endorse it.
CAROLINE HASKINS
uncovered in California is a nightmare.
NINA DIETZ
Matthew Prince Wants AI Companies
to Pay for Their Sins
The Cloudflare CEO joined The Big Interview to
KATIE DRUMMOND
deep underground.
A.R.E. TAYLOR
WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in
constant transformation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives—
from culture to business, science to design. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of
thinking, new connections, and new industries.
MORE FROM WIRED
REVIEWS AND GUIDES
Subscribe
Newsletters
Travel
FAQ
WIRED Staff
WIRED Education
Editorial Standards
Archive
RSS
Accessibility Help
Reviews
Buying Guides
Mattresses
Electric Bikes
Soundbars
Advertise
Contact Us
Manage Account
Jobs
Press Center
Condé Nast Store
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Your California Privacy Rights
© 2025 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site
may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Ad Choic